Universities make big decisions differently from most organizations. Shared governance brings many constituencies to the table, each with its own goals and expertise, and decisions come together through consensus. After years of research work alongside higher ed leaders, I’ve come to see that as a strength worth designing around. It’s also the most useful lens I know for understanding why program decisions take time to land, and what helps them move.
Institutions have strong tools for this work. Program prioritization has been a formal practice since Robert Dickeson introduced his framework in 1999, and more market data is available today than ever. Where I see reviews slow down is the moment when many constituencies need to agree on what the data means.
The national numbers reflect that moment. In the 2025 Survey of College and University Chief Academic Officers from Inside Higher Ed and Hanover Research, 55% of provosts said their institution lacks clear priorities among competing initiatives, and only 47% felt timelines for new initiatives were realistic. That matches what I hear from academic leaders, and the stakes keep rising. More than four dozen nonprofit colleges closed between 2022 and 2024.
What I’ve learned is that data does its best work when it’s paired with empathy for the people making a decision and authenticity to the institution making it. Here’s how that plays out in practice.
Takeaway 1: Reading Data in Context
Frameworks and rubrics are useful guides. The mathematically correct decision and the right decision for an institution can still differ, and that’s where context comes in.
A master’s program can look unprofitable on its own while half its courses are shared with another degree, which makes the unit economics far healthier than the spreadsheet suggests. A department can be underperforming while its dean is two years from retirement, and waiting for that transition may be the smarter move. A scoring model can’t hold that kind of nuance on its own, so I treat it as one input alongside institutional judgment.
Weighted rubrics deserve particular care. Models often expand as teams add competing stakeholder priorities, resulting in diluted, fractional weights. Run a program list through it, and it can recommend an obscure, highly specialized degree that scores well on paper and has little to do with the institution’s students or strengths.
Market signals need the same context. For years, national data showed econometrics growing at almost exactly the rate economics was declining. Looked at alone, econometrics seemed like a breakout opportunity. Looked at together, much of the shift traced back to STEM designation and immigration rules, with far less change in overall student demand. I encourage teams to look at related signals together before drawing conclusions.
This is also why I’m careful with DIY research tools. They’re fast and accessible, and for common questions they often land close to what an experienced analyst would say. On the edge cases, they can deliver data without the information around it, and a false positive looks just as convincing as a true signal. More and more, I think of my role as a data editor: the colleague who asks, “Did we look at this other source, too?”
Authenticity is its own data point. A program should make sense for the institution offering it. A small liberal arts college weighing a slate of engineering degrees because the market numbers look strong would want to ask whether those programs fit its faculty and its students. The strongest moves I’ve seen start from what a school is already known for and translate it into programs today’s students recognize as speaking to them. Geography works the same way. In federal data from fall 2023, nearly two-thirds of fully online students lived in the same state as their school. For many institutions, the biggest opportunity is close to home.
Takeaway 2: Leading with Empathy
My approach to all of this starts with empathy, an idea borrowed from design thinking. It begins with meeting partners where they are and sharing data in a way we can both interpret. My favorite moment on a call is when a partner tells me the conclusion before I reach my conclusion slide, because we’ve done the analysis together along the way.
Empathy matters most when the data is hard to hear. Imagine spending twenty years becoming an expert in your field and then learning that your program is in decline. It’s natural for that news to feel personal. Pointed questions in those moments often come from pressures that have little to do with the data itself, and patience goes a long way. Institutions can build that patience into their process on purpose.
Empathy also means making sure everyone is speaking the same language. One mix-up I’ve seen throughout my career involves retention. Online program partners often measure term-to-term retention: did a student who enrolled in one fall A continue in the next? Many institutions measure retention annually. The same program can look like 90% retention under one definition and closer to 60% under the other, and two well-meaning groups end up debating numbers that were never comparable. Enrollment works the same way, meaning headcount to one office and credit hours to another. Agreeing on definitions at the start of a review saves a lot of friction later.
When a review stalls, I’ve found the most helpful thing is specific, credible data that gives people permission to make a change they were hesitant to make. Two programs I worked with earlier in my career show what that looks like.
The first was an instructional design program, one of the earliest of its kind online. It thrived early, then leveled off once competitors came online too. When we looked at labor data alongside the program’s own applicants, we found a steady stream of resumes from people in corporate and adult learning, a different audience from the K-12 educators the program had always served, and those applicants weren’t enrolling. Adding a track for them met some resistance at first, since the team took great pride in its relationship with the local board of education. The data helped show that K-12 would remain an important part of the audience while no longer being all of it, and the new track saved the program.
The second was an applied behavior analysis program housed in a criminal justice department. Students preparing for autism intervention work kept getting routed through prison-focused fieldwork because that’s what the department offered, and they stuck with it because the program was one of the only online options in the field. A dedicated track raised understandable concerns about the program’s identity and home department. We worked through those questions together, and the new track revitalized the program.
In both cases, survey and application data gave people permission to do something they already suspected was right. Full consensus on a program decision may never be unanimous, and good evidence can give participants enough confidence to decide.
Takeaway 3: A Practical Path to Alignment
Based on what I’ve seen work, a few habits help program reviews move.
- Prepare an answer for every point on the decision spectrum.
People make decisions anywhere from purely logical to deeply emotional, and most land somewhere in between. That means having a case for each kind of stakeholder: the financial case for the CFO, the structural case for whoever manages course sequencing, the identity case for how the program fits the institution, and the student case for what it does for learners. A room of stakeholders is rarely convinced by a single argument. - Weigh sustainability alongside growth.
Going from five enrollments to ten is a 100% increase, while going from fifty to sixty is 20%, even though it’s more students and much harder to achieve in a market with a finite number of prospective students and a growing number of competitors. A more useful question is what a sustainable size looks like for each program. If a program thrives at 100 to 150 enrollments a year, the conversation below that range is about closing the gap, and the conversation within it is about protecting what’s working. - Bring in outside validation for high-stakes decisions.
Any group that works closely together for years can develop an echo chamber, and leaders who hold the budget benefit from an independent check on the excitement coming out of a conference or a department. The most helpful outside partners are the ones in the trenches with you, who understand the pressures because they face them too.
Questions for Your Next Review
Before your next program review, here are a few questions I’d bring to the team:
- Where might context change what our scoring model is telling us?
- Are we using the same definitions for the metrics we’re discussing?
- Does this program build on who we already are as an institution?
- What pressures might be shaping the concerns we’re hearing?
- Who outside this room could help us pressure-test the decision?
Looking for a partner to build a program evaluation process that balances evidence with institutional reality? Noodle brings market data and consumer insight into program decisions while keeping the people those decisions affect at the center.
Let’s talk.


